Dum Dums come in a lot of different flavors. I knew they were around a long time, but recently learned they’ve been around since 1924 from the Akron Candy Company and were bought by the Spangler Candy Company (Think candy canes and circus peanuts marshmallow candy) in 1953.
What is the Dum Dums mystery flavor?

The Dum Dums Mystery Flavor is a mix of two flavors. It’s made when the end of one batch of candy meets the beginning of the next, so a mystery Dum Dum never tastes the same twice. The full story, and the TV clip that revealed it, is further down.
My favorite Dum Dums flavors

As a kid, they were one of my favorite candies to get on Halloween night. My favorite flavors being cream soda and pineapple. So you can understand that when I bought a gigantic kitty litter sized plastic tub (1000 lollipops) of Dum Dums a few years ago for my kids (cough cough) and discovered that pineapple was no longer on their flavor list, I was pouty. I told my kids that the pineapple flavor was so good that I used to trade a handful to get that one flavor. I think the blueberry is a sorry excuse to include in their lineup of flavors. I always liked that they were small, but sadly the size makes them not the best choice for young children. But children that young probably shouldn’t be having lollipops anyway.
Dum Dums flavor list history
Here’s a Dum Dums flavor list history (source wikipedia):
- Banana (1960–1966, 2005–2008)
- Banana Split (2009–2011)
- Black Cherry (1968–1970)
- Blue Raspberry (1995–Present)
- Blueberry (2010–Present)
- Bubble Gum (2002–Present)
- Buttered Popcorn (2001)
- Butterscotch (original flavor, 1953–Present)
- Cherry (original flavor, 1953–Present)
- Cherry Cola (2005–2009)
- Chocolate (1955-1960, 1966–1975, 2002–2008)
- Coconut (2008–2010)
- Coconut-Pineapple (original flavor, 1953–1970, 2005–2008)
- Cotton Candy (2002–2014)
- Cream Soda (1968–Present)
- Dulce De Leche (2011–2013)
- Fruit Punch (2001–2002, 2011–2014)
- Grape (original flavor, 1953–Present)
- Lemon (original flavor, 1953–2000)
- Lime (original flavor, 1953–1991)
- Mango (2008–2013)
- Mystery (2001–Present)
- Orange (original flavor, 1953–2000, 2011–Present)
- Orange Cream (2000–2002)
- Peach (1987–2002)
- Peach-Mango (2013–Present)
- Pineapple (1970–2001)
- Pink Lemonade (2005–2009)
- Raspberry (1961–1968, 1975–1982)
- Raspberry Lemonade (2013–Present)
- Root Beer (1953–1961, 1968–Present)
- Sour Apple (1991–2000, 2001–Present)
- Strawberry (1954–Present)
- Strawberry Shortcake (2009–2011)
- Tangerine (2008–2011)
- Watermelon (1982–Present)
Update, November 2026: That list is from 2014. Here is the lineup now.
Dum Dums flavors today
Packs of Original Dum Dums have up to 16 flavors, according to Spangler, and larger bags generally have the best variety. The Original Mix flavors are:
- Blu Raspberry
- Bubble Gum
- Butterscotch
- Cherry
- Cotton Candy
- Cream Soda
- Fruit Punch
- Grape
- Lemon Lime
- Orange
- Peach Mango
- Pineapple
- Root Beer
- Sour Apple
- Strawberry
- Watermelon
- Mystery
The Super Treats Mix goes further, with Banana Split, Birthday Cake, Caramel Apple, Cinnamon Roll, Hot Chocolate, Strawberry Milkshake, and Sugar Cookie.
Limited edition and holiday flavors
I totally missed their new flavor lineup. Spangler partnered with Seven-up and Dr. Pepper and Hawaiian punch over the summer to introduce Fruit Juicy Red and Polar Blast flavors. They’ve also created holiday flavored Dum Dums (Available in 8 Limited Edition flavors including Merry Cherry, Sugar Plum, Hot Chocolate, Sugar Cookie, Gingerbread, Apple Cider, Green Apple Grinch and Polar Punch).
Update, November 2026: Those were the 2014 flavors. The Hawaiian Punch announcement is still online at PR Newswire, and the original page is saved at the Internet Archive. This Christmas, there are Dum Dums candy canes in Blu Raspberry, Cherry, and Watermelon.
Pineapple is back

So I feel a bit silly asking them to Bring Back Pineapple or Coconut-Pineapple, but I really want them to. haha. Ditch the blueberry! I don’t want to be too picky because of sugar imports. Candy is a luxury (and a treat) and I can’t say I’d pay much more than what I already do on candy.
Update, November 2026: When I first wrote this article, pineapple flavor was discontinued, but now pineapple flavor is back! If only I had known all these years! My kids are all grown now. I think I’ll pick up a bag of Dum Dums for Christmas candy.
Pineapple is on the Original Mix flavor list again, and it’s sold on its own in 50-count bags. Two more things changed along the way. Blueberry is out of the Original Mix, and a Pineapple Coconut flavor is part of the Tropical Mix and the Super Treats Mix.
Update, November 2026: The Bloomberg article on sugar imports is saved at the Internet Archive.
How Dum Dums are made
Here’s how Dum Dums are made: http://www.dumdumpops.com/downloads/dumdums-infographic.pdf
Update, November 2026: That file has moved. A copy from 2013 is saved at the Internet Archive, and Spangler now explains the steps on its How Dum Dums Are Made page.

Sugar and corn syrup are cooked in large copper kettles, then flavor and color are mixed in. The candy is kneaded, rolled into a rope, and fed into a press that shapes each pop and adds the paper stick at more than 1,000 pops a minute. About 12 million Dum Dums are made each day in Bryan, Ohio, according to Spangler.
Save Wraps for Stuff

They still have the save the wraps for stuff program, too. You can save Dum Dums wrappers to get a reduced price on unique Dum Dum Pop merchandise. This program was created when Spangler bought Dum Dums in 1953 and needed a way to promote them. Originally they offered merchandise such as baseballs, basketballs, yo-yo tops,footballs, bats, binoculars, toy cars, maps, checker set, balloons, space satellite launcher, ID bracelets, and flying saucers. They now offer some neat prizes such as stickers, sweatshirts, mouse pads, water bottles, backpacks, etc. The prizes aren’t free, but are discounted when you save the wrappers.
Update, November 2026: The program has ended. It started in 1959, stopped in 1994, came back in 2001, and ended again in 2020, according to Spangler. Candy Industry reported the ending in May 2020, and the 2014 Save Wraps page is saved at the Internet Archive.
The Dum Dums mystery flavor, explained

But what about the Dum Dums mystery flavor? If you’ve enjoyed them as much as I do, you probably know it’s not a consistent single flavor combination. I used to try to guess the flavors and could sometimes identify it and sometimes I couldn’t. On the Spangler website FAQ section it says: “The Mystery Flavor™ is a secret. We can only reveal that the Mystery Flavor continuously changes and is not limited to current Dum Dums flavors. It’s up to Dum Dums fans to guess the flavor of these mysterious pops”.
But according to Mental Floss: The Mystery Flavor pop is a mixture of two flavors that come together when the end of one batch of candy meets the beginning of the next batch. Rather than shutting down to clean out the candy equipment between flavors, Spangler turned lemons into lemonade and made pops out of the combination of flavors – the tail end of the old, and the beginning of the new. The candy lines keep running continuously, and the Mystery Flavor pops are a surprise treat every time.
This was originally revealed on Unwrapped. too.

Is the mystery flavor always two flavors?
Not always. The Mystery Flavor joined the mix in 2001, and Spangler says it isn’t limited to current flavors. In 2015, a Mystery Mania promotion put three unusual flavors in a special mystery wrapper: buttered popcorn, bacon, and pizza.
A little Dum Dums history

The name was picked because it was easy for children to say and remember, according to Spangler. The first year Spangler made Dum Dums, it turned out 84 million pops in seven flavors: lemon, lime, orange, coconut-pineapple, cherry, grape, and butterscotch. Four of those are still in the Original Mix. Lemon and lime now share one pop.
By 1959, banks and doctors’ offices were handing out Dum Dums as a treat. The brand turned 100 in 2024, and there have been more than 100 flavors over the years, according to Snack Food & Wholesale Bakery.
Dum Dums wrapper crafts
I love the Dum Dums holiday craft section. It’s easy to see that any of the “other wrapped lollipop” crafts online could easily be substituted with Dum Dums.
Update, November 2026: That craft page has moved. A copy from 2014 is saved at the Internet Archive.
You can make a wrapper bracelet by using Dum Dum wrappers (or Starburst or gum wrappers), too.
Dum Dums FAQ
What is the Dum Dums mystery flavor? It’s a mix of two flavors, made when one batch of candy ends and the next begins. It changes all the time, so one mystery pop may not taste like the next.
When did the Dum Dums mystery flavor come out? Spangler released the Mystery Flavor in 2001.
How many Dum Dums flavors are there? Packs of Original Dum Dums have up to 16 flavors. Seasonal and specialty mixes add more.
Is pineapple still a Dum Dums flavor? Yes. Pineapple is in the Original Mix and is also sold as a single flavor.
Are Dum Dums allergy friendly? Spangler says Dum Dums do not contain peanuts, tree nuts, milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, wheat, sesame, or gluten, and are made on dedicated equipment. They are also kosher certified. Check the label on your bag.
How many calories are in a Dum Dum? Each pop has fewer than 26 calories.
How long do Dum Dums last? They have a shelf life of 36 months. Each package has a Best By date.
Have a bowl of Halloween candy left? The guide to what to do with leftover Halloween candy has 14 ideas. For more old favorites, see Vintage 80’s Candy and the History of Animal Crackers.
What was your favorite flavor?





